AI/Gemini Knows About Singing

As I was driving home from an appointment today, I experimented by asking Gemini (Argon) – through the connection with my Android Auto app – to write the post you are about to read. I mentioned in very few words, to the effect that singing doesn’t depend on merely the physical or the mental/expressive. Following is the doc that Google saved for me, and I retrieved it from my Google Drive. The entire exchange in the car took less time than it takes you to read this post. I stand by the post, and agree with it as written (unchanged by me). It is excellent, as far as it goes:

Trusting the Instrument: The Art of Letting the Body Sing

When we think about singing, we often split it into two distinct categories: the physical mechanics—breath support, vocal cord closure, posture—and the emotional expression. However, true artistry in singing happens at the intersection of body, mind, and spirit. It is not strictly a physical endeavor, nor is it purely an expressive one.

The Connection Between Inspiration and the Body

The human voice is a unique instrument because the performer and the instrument are one and the same. When a singer is moved by inspiration—whether artistic, emotional, or spiritual—the brain conceives a sound long before the physical action takes place. For the music to flow freely, the singer must learn to trust that the body knows how to respond to that internal inspiration.

When fear or overthinking takes over, we attempt to micromanage every muscle, leading to tension and strain. But when trust is placed in the body’s innate design, physical mechanics align naturally with artistic vision, creating a unified and authentic expression of faith and music.

Key Takeaways for Vocalists

  • Mind-Body Connection: Allow your artistic imagination to guide your physical movement rather than forcing vocal technique.
  • Releasing Control: Trust the training you have done so that in the moment of performance, inspiration can lead.
  • Holistic Singing: View the voice as a bridge between the inner spirit and the outer world.

Advice on Artistry for Singers

I just came across this email that I wrote to the ten students enrolled in the 2018 edition of our beautiful program, Vienna: Language of Lieder. I invite you to give it a look today, as it may inform your own learning and teaching. Let me know if it helps!

First of all, know that each of you is making strides towards finding and developing your own artistic center. Parallel with and essential to that process, your abilities as singer, actor, interpreter of literature (technique, you might say) are moving forward – sometimes dramatically so!

It occurs to me that some of you (since you are all so young!) may be unclear or confused, because you perceive differences of opinion and method between two or more of your teachers here. As I said at the beginning, know that we are not in lock step, though there are essential things that are common in our work. At the same time, each artist/teacher has unique preferences.

Put the above individuality together with the fact that each of you is a “moving target” in each session, and it becomes even more difficult for you to find absolute, fundamental “rules” about artistry.

Failsafe, dogmatic instructions for the “correct” performance of anything are suspect, at best. You’ll be wise to stop looking for the perfect interpretation of anything.

For example, something so basic as tempo: One teacher may give you a faster tempo, perhaps because you are lethargic, lost in your head. Another teacher may insist on a slower tempo on the same piece, to help you find gravity and more intense delivery of the song’s essence.

Your privilege and your responsibility is to synthesize the various input you receive – finally coming up with performances you are convinced honor “the rules,” yet they will be marked with your own fingerprints, your own DNA.

Think of a cake recipe. Some ingredients are essential, or you have a cookie instead of a cake, yet there is plenty room and need for customization. True, a freshly-prepared hamburger at McDonald’s will be consistent under any authorized Golden Arches, but you are still eating a Mickey D’s burger – generally not the most nutritious or interesting meal.

I’d be delighted to talk with any of you about these ideas. Know that this program exists to give you tools, knowledge, skill, experience, exposure – all things that you incorporate to be an artist, not merely a conveyor of others’ preferences. One cannot be an artist, while holding a Fundamentalist mindset.

I’m proud of what you’re all doing in these weeks! EE